The Pros And Cons Of Architectural Shingles For Roof Replacement

Posted on: 26 April 2023

When it comes time for a residential roof replacement, you have an opportunity for an upgrade rather than just re-roofing with the same product. If your home currently has low-quality 3-tab asphalt shingles, this is a chance to upgrade to a higher-quality asphalt shingle like an architectural shingle. But is it really worth it? Here are the pros and cons of choosing architectural asphalt shingles for your upcoming roof replacement.


Longer Life

Compared to lower-quality asphalt shingles, architectural shingles have a much longer life span, lasting between 25 and 30 years in most cases. That's because architectural shingles are made of a tough fiberglass layer between two sandwiching layers of asphalt. The upper layer of asphalt contains mineral granules to create a tough protective top layer. The product is thicker and made with higher-quality materials. It will withstand impacts, windstorms, and UV rays better.

Wind Resistance

As mentioned, one of the major benefits of architectural shingles is added wind resistance. Because the product is thicker and therefore heavier weight, it's better able to offer increased wind resistance. If you live in an area where hurricanes or windstorms are common events, this type of shingle is a sound investment.

Energy Efficiency

Another benefit you can expect to enjoy with architectural shingles is added energy efficiency. Some architectural shingles have granules with highly reflective properties that can help reflect solar heat in the summer to keep your house cooler. These lower temperatures can also add to the roof's longevity.


Architectural asphalt shingles come in a wide variety of textures and shades so that you can customize the aesthetic of your roof to your existing home. This isn't as easy with a low-quality asphalt shingle.


Partly because of the options for variety but also the quality of materials, architectural shingles have a more polished aesthetic than 3-tab. You can guarantee that you'll be able to find a product that complements the look of your home and looks good doing it.



Compared to a low-quality asphalt shingle like 3-tab, architectural shingles will cost a little more upfront. You can expect to pay between $4.50 and $12.25 per square foot for architectural shingles compared to 3-tab which tops out around $8.25 per square foot. However, when you consider the small increase compared to the added longevity, it makes a lot of sense to opt for the increase upfront in order to take advantage of the durability later on. 

For more info, contact a local company like MCSquared Roofing.